College Saving

Reducing income during retirement to qualify for healthcare subsidy

The recent passage of the healthcare overhaul has prompted me to look closer at the issue of early retirement. There is a choice to work less and spend more time with family. Or even retire early and have the government subsidies your health care insurance by keeping income levels below 4x the poverty rate (see this Health Reform Subsidy Calculator).

The following is a list of items to reduce income:

  • If you have kids, and you want to help to pay for their college, plan to have more of it funded by 529 accounts. If you have to sell investments or draw down from tax-deferred accounts, that increases your MAGI.
  • Pay off mortgage if possible to eliminate income requirement. Again, same thing as college funding, if you have to sell investments or draw down from tax-deferred accounts, that increases your MAGI. Without a mortgage, you have less need to realize capital gains or draw down from tax-deferred accounts.
  • Derive income for ongoing expenses from tax exempt bonds (tax exempt income does not figure into MAGI).
  • Use a short term tax exempt fund to hold non-immediate cash needs instead of a high yield savings account. Perhaps top up the checking account once or twice a month. This reduces the amount of interest payments reported in MAGI.
  • Shift equity investments into lower yield equivalents, while still keeping the general composition of the portfolio reasonably unchanged. One potential candidate would be to invest in US LargeCap Growth instead of US LargeCap Blend. Does not work for US SmallCap (US SmallCap Growth has a poor historical record).
  • Invest in rental property and use rental income to fund ongoing expenses (rental income is typically offset by property depreciation).
  • Look into MLP investments that shield income for as long as the investment is not sold (you can control when to sell if necessary).
  • Delay signing up social security.

Even though it looks like I could potentially benefit from the healthcare reform if I retire early, I don’t agree with the changes. They simply penalize people who are successful and are a disincentive to work. This can’t be good for the economy. But that is another story.

Tax harvesting from 529 plan?

If you started contributing to a 529 plan some time in 2007, the chances are that the plan is in the RED (with capital losses) due to the recent stock market conditions.

A thought came to my mind — since unqualified distributions from the 529 plan are taxable, is it possible to tax harvest from the 529 plan?

I asked this question on the Bogleheads forum, and here’s a reply from LH2004 (who had previously demonstrated to have very good knowledge on tax matters):

Yes. See “Losses on QTP Investments” in Publication 970. You’ll be subject to the 2% of AGI floor, though, so you’ll need to have really extreme losses, or a big account, or low AGI, or other miscellaneous itemized deductions to reach that floor.

Alternatively, under the IRS’s new theory regarding wash sales, you could take the position that a sale of an individual portfolio in the 529 plan at a loss, followed by a purchase of a substantially identical fund in your taxable account, is a wash sale, increasing your basis in the newly-purchased fund, which you could then immediately sell at a loss; that would be an aggressive position to take.

Taylor Larimore kindly found the link to the relevant section in Publication 970 — :

Losses on QTP Investments

If you have a loss on your investment in a QTP account, you may be able to take the loss on your income tax return. You can take the loss only when all amounts from that account have been distributed and the total distributions are less than your unrecovered basis. Your basis is the total amount of contributions to that QTP account. You claim the loss as a miscellaneous itemized deduction on Schedule A (Form 1040), line 23, subject to the 2%-of-adjusted-gross-income limit.

If you have distributions from more than one QTP account during a year, you must combine the information (amount of distribution, basis, etc.) from all such accounts in order to determine your taxable earnings for the year. By doing this, the loss from one QTP account reduces the distributed earnings (if any) from any other QTP accounts.

At this point, it doesn’t look like something I would do.

Ohio State 529 plan lowers fees again

Last September, I posted some information about the 529 plans that I am contributing to. The contributions have been on auto-pilot and I did not get the chance to check on the plans until today.

I was pleasantly surprised to learn that the Ohio State’s College Advantage plan has lowered its fees again from May 2007. If I remember correctly, it last lowered its fees last year.

The reduction is not much, averaging about 2 basis points reduction for all the investment options that I had chosen. But, I am encouraged to see that at least it is a step in the right direction.

The following shows the old and new expense ratios.


My overall expense ratio for my 529 portfolio drops from 0.373% to 0.357%. 😉