Refinance Started With First Internet Bank

It looks like the refinance train is here again. Due to the weak economy statistics, mortgage interest rates have dropped to rates not seen since October 2010.

Last week on 6/1/2011, I requested quotes from two brokers and two banks to refinance my 30-year fixed jumbo-conforming mortgage. The criteria for my refinance is that it has to be no-point and is either no-cost or has very low-fee.

Broker H

I have worked with broker H for previous refinances before. She quoted me a rate of 4.375% with a 0.375% fee.

Broker A

This broker was recommended to me from a co-worker. She told me the rate was 4.375% with no-point and no-fee at that particular instance, but the rate was valid only on that day and it was already too late to prepare the documents to lock in to that rate. She requires an upfront $25 for the credit report and another $50 to submit the loan (which will be reimbursed at closing).

Bank of America

I received a quote of 4.75% for a no-cost no-fee loan. My current loan is 4.625%, so this option is a no-no.

First Internet Bank of Indiana (FirstIB)

Based on many good reviews, including that from TheFinanceBuff, I have been watching the online rate quote from FirstIB. The online rate quote on this particular day was 4.375% with ~$1200 fee.

What I did

I decided to wait for a better rate from the brokers, and at the same time, to submit the application with FirstIB and wait for the right moment to strike.

FirstIB does not charge a fee to submit the online application, so it was a relatively easy decision, with the only “cost” being a hit on my credit report.

I submitted the online application with FirstIB’s Gary (who has received many good reviews). I received a call back from Gary about 3 hours later. He told me the rate had improved after my application was submitted, and the new rate was 4.375% with a $5000 credit. This credit can be used to pay for the closing costs (estimated to be $3000), with the remainder going into the impound account to pay for future property taxes and insurance.

Since this mortgage rate and fee scenario met all my criteria, I locked the rate with Gary on the spot. Gary told me that he expects the refinance to close in 25 days.

I am keeping my fingers crossed and will post the timeline once my refinance with FirstIB is completed.


  1. Ace

    How did the refi with First IB end up?

  2. indexfundfan (Post author)

    It’s completed. Sorry for not updating. Old loan was paid off on 6/28. FirstIB delivered as promised.

    In fact I am now in the process of another refi with FirstIB, lowering the rate to 4.125% (same 30-yr loan).

  3. savvyhousewife

    I was looking to refinance my home mortgage which currently is at 4.25%. After doing a lot of research on the internet,I narrowed it down to Amerisave and First internet Bank. I could get a 3.37% rate with about $3000 in credit towards closing cost. I worked with the officer Melanie Smith. She was very helpful and we locked in the rate. I have a credit score of average from three companies-790 ,very little debt. I had bought the house for $545,000 a year ago.
    I was feeling pretty good about refinancing and saving some money which could go towards paying my teenager’s car insurance.
    Imagine the shock when I got the property appraiser’s report -valuing at $435,00.How can the value of house drop from year ago when another appraiser valued it at $545,000 to $435,00?
    Also interesting was the fact that the appraiser took the pictures of my kids bedroom where the bed was not made and the bonus room where all the kids mess could be seen but not the family room or living room or master bedroom. Also the houses picked for comparison were picked deliberately that had the lowest value.
    So the company makes money on the appraisal and the bank does not have to refinance at the low rate.

  4. InDebted

    Well, I also decided to wait for the banks to get lower with their interest rates until the middle of 2012 – and I got a reduction from 4.8%to 4%. I guess patience pays itself sometimes…


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Anti-spam image